alert

Institutional tensions increase scrutiny of Brazil’s Supreme Federal Court

On 9 September 2026, tensions surrounding Brazil’s Supreme Federal Court (STF) and the investigation into Banco Master continued amid questions over relationships between financial-sector actors, public authorities and members of the Court. The situation intensified following the disclosure of messages involving Justice Alexandre de Moraes and Daniel Vorcaro, former controller of Banco Master, as well as disagreements between STF justices over the investigation.

The dispute deepened after Justice André Mendonça ordered the removal of the Director-General of the Federal Police and the Director of Police Intelligence, a decision subsequently reversed by Justice Flávio Dino, adding to institutional tensions involving the STF, the Federal Police and the Federal Government.

Civil society actors have called for greater transparency and accountability, clearer rules on conflicts of interest and recusal, and stronger ethical standards for STF justices. Initiatives such as Ninguém Acima da Lei (No One Above the Law) have framed these demands around strengthening democratic institutions and public trust.

President Luiz Inácio Lula da Silva also called for the disclosure of confidential information related to the Banco Master investigation, arguing that transparency was needed to ensure proper investigation and prevent selective leaks from interfering with the democratic and electoral process. These concerns are especially relevant ahead of the 2026 elections, as disputes involving the STF, the Federal Police and the Executive could reinforce perceptions of institutional bias and undermine confidence in the democratic process.

For civic space, unresolved concerns over potential conflicts of interest and the conduct of the investigation could deepen institutional distrust and undermine the credibility of accountability mechanisms through which civil society seeks to scrutinise public institutions. At the same time, mobilisation around judicial accountability demonstrates continued space for public scrutiny and advocacy and could contribute to stronger safeguards on conflicts of interest, recusal and ethical standards within the STF.

THIS ALERT RELATES TO

COUNTRY

ENABLING PRINCIPLE

ALERT TYPE

Search

People searched for